The logical contradiction of an industry headed toward ruin

It seems to be an oxymoron.
A business that is robbing it's customers blind should be doing great profit-wise, right?
In reality it is a sign of a terminal illness.

In 2001 Enron was defrauding California of billions of dollars. The following year it was bankrupt.
During the housing bubble the financial sector defrauded their customers on an epic scale. They all ended up insolvent and imploded the global economy.
Since the crash the banking sector has continued to commit fraud, but at the same time it's been laying off employees by the tens of thousands.
Wells Fargo was cutting headcount even while stealing from their customers.
Look at the UBS trading floor from 8 years ago, contrasted with one from this year.
UBS trading floor 2008.jpg
UBS trading floor 2016-.jpg

However, I don't want to talk about the financial sector today.
I want to talk about the health care industry.

Forget about the subprime mortgage collapse. The health care sector is nursing its own toxic mess, with soaring debt, the analysts say. “As a nation, we have to step up our game and get on top of it; this is a huge issue,” said Chris Oretis, a former Washington lobbyist who now works as executive vice president in the life insurance secondary markets at GWG Holdings.
As industry spending and debt servicing rage out of control, health care is ranked as the No. 1 US “systemic recession risk” in a new report.

Health care fraud, just in Medicare and Medicaid, ranges in the hundreds of billions of dollars.
At the same time over half a million Americans are forced to declare bankruptcy every year because of medical bills. The whole system is built to be abused.

The way it works now, the so-called “providers” (doctors, hospitals) refuse to post the cost of any service, and then charge whatever they feel they can extract, subject to an abstruse and dishonest ceremonial “negotiation” with the insurance company. The result: hospital and insurance executives get paid multi-million dollar salaries, doctors get to drive fine German cars, and the patient gets financially ass-raped, kicked to the curb, and eventually stuffed into the bankruptcy courts.

There is no other industry in which the costs are completely unknown to the customer beforehand. Meanwhile, the prices of services can only be comparable to military defense contractors.

Despite all this fraud and wealth extraction from working-class people, like Enron and the financial industry before it, the health care industry is in deep trouble.

Health-care sector debt has soared 308% since 2009, the depth of the Great Recession which elegantly bypassed the sector. Over the same period, GDP has grown 30%, and overall jobs have grown only 18%. Thus health-care sector debt has grown 10 times faster than GDP and 17 times faster than private-sector jobs, “exceeding multiples of prior finance and energy sector boom-and-bust cycles.”

US-healthcare-debt-gdp-jobs.png

All that debt, the result of a merger binge, needs to be serviced. That normally means passing along the costs to the customers. However, the costs are already out of control, beyond the ability of many to pay, and crushing the general economy. So passing along the costs of this is not a realistic option.

US-healthcare-costs-per-family-of-4.png
US-healthcare-debt-growth-per-65person.png

The math doesn't add up. The greed has been too great. The theft has been too rapacious.
Now the first signs of the inevitable are starting to be seen.

The first murmurs of early trouble may have been detected.
“Companies in the health care sector are starting to lay people off,” said John Burns, CEO of John Burns Real Estate Consulting, an independent research and consulting firm on macro trends, such as the health care and technology sectors, that drive the US housing market...
“It could be like a Lehman Brothers scenario, where a couple of big health care companies take the economy down,” Burns told The Post.

When the next recession hits, which will be soon, the bankruptcies will start.

Share
up
0 users have voted.

Comments

Steven D's picture

or if they are they're laying them off with a multi-million going away present.

up
0 users have voted.

"You can't just leave those who created the problem in charge of the solution."---Tyree Scott

Lily O Lady's picture

goes after what the 99% has left. Scraping the bottom of the barrel is sure to get ugly.

up
0 users have voted.

"The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power. Now do you begin to understand me?" ~Orwell, "1984"

Lookout's picture

The same type of fraud that occurred at Enron has been cropping up in the charter school sector. A handful of school officials have been caught using the Enron playbook to divert funding slated for these schools into their own pockets.
https://theconversation.com/is-charter-school-fraud-the-next-enron-74020

up
0 users have voted.

“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”

We need to overhaul providers before we can get universal healthcare. Insurance companies used to be able to rein them in but Obamacare has removed their incentive to police costs. At least that's what they thought going into the exchanges...Had insurance companies maintained this role they would not be dropping out of the exchanges nor have to raise premiums to ridiculous levels. But they were very intent on "hacking" the profit cap by letting providers and drug companies jack up their rates....

up
0 users have voted.
Alligator Ed's picture

@eltee Insurance companies commit fraud. Pharma, physicians, medical providers commit fraud. Are we to let one type of fraud continue while we attend to the other? This would be like locking the front door when thieves are also breaking in the back door.

up
0 users have voted.
Alligator Ed's picture

Previously I have published a few articles relating to what MFA would not solve, but I won't link to them here.

My understanding of this essay is as follows: there are two co-existent problems both of which have been compound by additional greed and by gross misunderstanding.

The first could be called "Killing the Goose that lays the Golden Egg". This applies to over-borrowing and over-consolidation. The result of these two inter-related aspects is that debt rises much more than is reasonable based on any reasonable projection of future earnings. The American economy has been and is being pillaged by the Oligarch-Insurance-Pharma cabal. Stagnant and actual falling wages have not kept pace even with expected inflation. People are being gouged so hard, it is like getting blood from a turnip (pardon for the mixed metaphors). Regardless of the true number of annual medical bankruptcies, they are significant. These ruin lives, produce depression (leading to drug abuse and suicide) and homelessness (homelessness of course have adverse consequences on the entire housing sector). People, aka consumers of healthcare, are being forced to pay debt service for unwise financial moves, or moves that may be actually fraudulent.

The second lies in the Janus-like medical code/medical billing debacle. ICD-9, the previous diagnostic disease coding standard, which directly affects billing, was relatively simple. ICD-10 was devised as an aid to research. There are 5 codes for Alligator-related injury about which I earlier posted. This is ridiculous. The Purpose was to provide a more accurate research data base so that all types of medical issues, whether congenital, acquired, accidental, iatrogenic, could be separately analyzed for frequency and total budgetary expense. It is clearly unworkable in the clinical setting. The other Janus-face of this over-meticulous coding requirement, is not only abuse of the physician's time taken away from direct patient care but also two unintended consequences. The first is utter confusion as to how properly bill for a procedure, knowing, as all physicians do, that over-coding (i.e., more than the procedure is worth) can lead to civil and criminal penalties. Paradoxically this unnecessary over-complication introduces yet more possibilities for provider fraud. Many codes are iffy and some are downright wrong. Computer programs are unable to evaluate over-coding which involve evaluation of numerous individual unique circumstances. Needless to say, the insurers and government don't care about under-coding because they save money. This accentuates the basic unfairness of the coding system.

Yes, provider fraud is rampant in particular areas, large population ones such as L.A. Patient fraud is also rampant--i.e., faked injuries either under premises liability claims or worker's compensation claims. Next there is the obscene fraud that "Insurance" companies actually provide benefits for health-related problems. To which must be added the even more obscene over-compensation of the higher echelon executives whose decrees make patients jump through interminable hoops, only to have legitimate claims denied. I could go on but enough for now.

up
0 users have voted.

You can't compare policies. You can only compare premiums. I tried to get BCBS to compare their two policies in the FEHB system. They acknowledged that the negotiated rate is probably different on the two policies but they can't tell me numbers unless I give them a provider name AND a service code. They can all be different. You can't compare anything but the rate. so I have the more expensive policy in the HOPE that it covers better than the cheaper policy.

I went to the pharmacy to get drug prices because one policy has dollar co-pays and the other has percentage co-pays. But again, the base price differs by pharmacy and policy number. And the pharmacist can't or won't tell me the price on a different policy.

up
0 users have voted.

I've seen lots of changes. What doesn't change is people. Same old hairless apes.

Though I must admit that I didn't see it playing out this way.
(pats self on back, wrenches shoulder, goes bankrupt, dies under bridge)

up
0 users have voted.

On to Biden since 1973

Pluto's Republic's picture

@doh1304

…so much. Get well soon Wink

up
0 users have voted.

____________________

The political system is what it is because the People are who they are. — Plato
Pluto's Republic's picture

In this case, simple.

The issues are not clearly labeled, which can obscure the oft-repeating patterns. That can make the solution seem complex when it is not. Otherwise, this is another well-structured presentation.

You are describing our unique, ideologically-riddled economic system from which specific control valves and regulators have been removed. It has a steampunk look, but it works well enough if you know its eccentricities and where to kick it.

However, I don't want to talk about the financial sector today.
I want to talk about the health care industry.

Although much of the health care industry operates inside the financial sector (insurance, for example), these can be isolated for discussion-sake. It's much harder to isolate the financial sector (banking) from the economic system. In the real world, it cannot be done.

Next, you describe one of those investment sector bubbles (are there any other kind?) that periodically plague the economic system, in this case the cash flow of health care commodity (parts and labor) expansion investment, not to be conflated with consumer health care debt. This bubble is the ego-debt of merger fever among health care corporations, much of it already extracted in stock buybacks and CEO bonuses. Their shareholders can pay for their greed and inability to perform. They can also take a haircut on any bankruptcies.

You talk about greed as if it was an occasional variable rather that the pillar upon which this nation and its system of government was founded. Greed is what inspired predatory capitalism, the lifeblood of our economy. It is greed that decides what parts of the Federal government to privatize and how much the government (taxpayers) will be forced to "single-pay" the corporations to run the government that they now own. The government also indemnifies them for mismanagement, and picks up the tab on any losses and bankruptcies the new owners incur.

Finally, you close with:

The math doesn't add up. The greed has been too great.
The theft has been too rapacious.
Now the first signs of the inevitable are starting to be seen.

“Companies in the health care sector are starting to lay people off,” said John Burns, CEO of John Burns Real Estate Consulting, an independent research and consulting firm on macro trends, such as the health care and technology sectors, that drive the US housing market… It could be like a Lehman Brothers scenario, where a couple of big health care companies take the economy down,” Burns told The Post

.

When the next recession hits, which will be soon, the bankruptcies will start.

First off, Burns clearly has PTSD from the last recession, and everything looks like a real estate crisis to him. He can be safely dismissed.

We already configure the various components of our economic system to weather business cycles and storms. In 250 years of local banking and 2,500 years of Middle East and Islamic banking, we've seen it all. We can see trouble a long way off. We know where the next bubbles (unsustainable imbalances) are and we know exactly how to regulate them back into a safe range. (With Goldman Sachs embedded at both Treasury and the Federal Reserve, you never really know.) If we decide not to regulate or to de-regulate, we know with great accuracy how a bubble will resolve and how that resolution will affect other economic components. We even know how to adjust other components to hide the bubble, and we know who is going to pick up the tab when the bubble does pop. The system itself is no more complex than a steam engine.

I reject the entire notion of economic surprise.

The only problems the US economic system has come from political ideology and psychological denial. Here, we get into the realms of mental illness and religious obsession. So let's talk about solutions, instead.

The US has only one economic problem. It cannot tell the difference between a private business, a public utility, and a natural resource. The latter two need to be nationalized along with anything else that is too big to fail, especially the large banks.

I say, get it done or burn it down.

up
0 users have voted.

____________________

The political system is what it is because the People are who they are. — Plato
Mark from Queens's picture

@Pluto's Republic

The US has only one economic problem. It cannot tell the difference between a private business, a public utility, and a natural resource. The latter two need to be nationalized along with anything else that is too big to fail, especially the large banks.

I say, get it done or burn it down.

Thanks.

up
0 users have voted.

"If I should ever die, God forbid, let this be my epitaph:

THE ONLY PROOF HE NEEDED
FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WAS MUSIC"

- Kurt Vonnegut

importer's picture

@Pluto's Republic One of my sons has COPD, happily, he can still work in his profession which is the high 5-low 6 figures. He pays large deductibles for hospitalization and the FIRST thing they want to know is how he will pay. He can still pay, but the costs are ridiculous.

One of my other sons has Chronic Heart failure from the flu, apparently, he's 42. He hasn't been able to work much and hasn't been able to get insurance, even OBAMACARE was more than he could afford and has the tax penalties to prove it. Applying for disability, which he is loath to do, takes a couple years and doesn't yield enough to live on. Keeping a roof over his head has become a major effort. He went in the hospital in October for less than 24 hours and was presented with a bill for almost $18K!!!!! No one can deal with this kind of cost. Health savings accounts are a JOKE. Because he doesn't have insurance, the hospital can bill whatever they want. He filed for and got Medicare which will pick up most of the cost, but also reserves the right to go after his house. The bill collectors go after whatever Medicare won't pay. So the Republican mantra that ANYONE can go to the emergency room for treatment FOR FREE is BS. You might be able to fend off the cost; but, in the end, if you have any assets, they reserve the right to go after them. He is now facing medical bankruptcy, along with losing his business and having to sell his house.

Some government - city, county, state or federal should be involved in certain areas of the economy. As you state, healthcare used to be in the public sector with community hospitals and relatively low costs with many workers having good health insurance. We had PUBLIC UTILITIES because that is what they were - not-for-profit public goods provided by the community. Public education is under seige, now, because that is another pool of money the rich/corp want to grab. Don't get me started on "natural resources" that have been plundered not only by our own greedy corporations, but by greedy entities worldwide. We just can't wait to give away that which is inherently the life blood of the country.

As you state, if we can't fix this, we need to tear it down - but where to start? The momentum is with the corporations, they have the WH, the Congress and now the Supreme Court. Nothing is going to change that short of open revolt.

up
0 users have voted.
orlbucfan's picture

Rec'd!! Smile

up
0 users have voted.

Inner and Outer Space: the Final Frontiers.